Jump to content
British Speedway Forum

Sgp Challenge Final Sat 20th Sept


Recommended Posts

 

No they won't. One meeting doesn't say anything since Harris had fluke for the second straight year.

That is why the world championship is decided over a series and not one single meeting.

One year is a fluke, 2 years is isn't

Bomber has qualified by right, I really hope he gets top 8 next season and shuts everyone up. It was only a couple of years ago he was joint fourth

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Time will tell but do any of us get the GP field we want? The top 8 qualify of right but all manner of occurences can keep a top rider out of the top 8, Three qualify from the Challenge but as we saw tonight, two falls can knock out the sure-fire winner, Then there are the wildcards. No matter who gets picked it sure won't please everybody. Finally we have the staging nation picking their own wildcard...Jason Bunyan anyone?.Sure as eggs are eggs, when the 16 line up for the 1st. GP of 2015 we will all be saying "x" should not be here or "y" should be here. It's the way it is.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

The only debate on who should and shouldn't be there is the wild cards... The top 8 and GP qualifiers are there on merit.

 

Everyone saying Harris shouldn't be there yet Doyley deserves to be?? Why?? Doyley isn't that much better than Harris... If at all.... and I doubt bomber has anywhere near the collateral that the big boys have, which is half the battle IMO

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

The only debate on who should and shouldn't be there is the wild cards... The top 8 and GP qualifiers are there on merit.

 

Everyone saying Harris shouldn't be there yet Doyley deserves to be?? Why?? Doyley isn't that much better than Harris... If at all.... and I doubt bomber has anywhere near the collateral that the big boys have, which is half the battle IMO

I for one am not saying Bomber should not be there. I have been critical of his inconsistency but not of the man or his ability. I have a lot of admiration for his spirit and wish him a far better year next year.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Despite being one of his critics,well done to Harris qualified on merit so deserves to be in GP next year ,if there are so many quality riders out there that everybody seems to think perhaps a rethink of the qualifying system needs looked at.As I said earlier in the season the GP needs too deal with the "also rans" during the season.Say the top 12 are the only ones guaranteed a place in the next GP meeting.

Edited by Fromafar
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Arson fire, agree with everything you say. Bomber has been on fire for the Bees lately and it looks like his good form has continued into the GP challenge. He's earned his place and I'm delighted for him. Well done Bomber

  • Like 2
Link to comment
Share on other sites

All good in saying his form in EL is has been great recently but what happens to that form when he rides in the GP?

The past is a different country.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Equally, if he is so good why has he not scored more points in the 2014 gp's and higher up the standings. Apart from an odd race this year his performance has not been gp standard - IMO

I don't recall seeing any post saying how good or bad he is or was. However, the fact remains he finished in the top three of the challenge on merit, ahead of, presumably, other riders who you feel justify being included ahead of him. How so? He has qualified and they haven't, so how poor does that make all of those? Please do think about what you post before you post it.

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Some real first class keyboard jockeys in here tonight,slagging Kilderman's off,seriously,an idiot? A huge pressure cooker meeting,a GP place at stake,the guy rides like he does for the results he gets,that style goes a long.long way,just look where he is right now,look how far it got him last night too.

 

Nobody moans when it pays off and the entertainment factor's high,but it bites sometimes and today was one of those days,lighten up

 

Good for Harris too,well deserved and hopefully he can make a better go of the 2015 GPs

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Some real first class keyboard jockeys in here tonight,slagging Kilderman's off,seriously,an idiot? A huge pressure cooker meeting,a GP place at stake,the guy rides like he does for the results he gets,that style goes a long.long way,just look where he is right now,look how far it got him last night too.

 

Nobody moans when it pays off and the entertainment factor's high,but it bites sometimes and today was one of those days,lighten up

 

Good for Harris too,well deserved and hopefully he can make a better go of the 2015 GPs

Agree had can you criticise an entertainer like Kildermand ,a breath of fresh air.
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Harris has not "earned his place on merit".

 

Fact _ he did not "earn his place on merit" for the SGP Challenge on merit so he did not earn any place on merit.

 

Fact _ he squeaked it in to the Challenge by default but made the best of that.

 

To his congratulators do any of you seriously think he'll qualify for the top 8 by the end of 2015?

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

If Mr. A. Rossiter is reading this tonight

 

Please Please Please can you bring back Doyley and let PK go.

 

PK falls off far too many times and its always at important times as well whilst Doyley is one of the best in the world at the moment.

So far this year you have wanted SG, Morris, Dak, Greaves and now Killer sacked all based on watching bet365 or reading updates like tonight. I think you are clueless to be honest. No one in their right mind wouldnt want Killer back at Swindon.

Some real first class keyboard jockeys in here tonight,slagging Kilderman's off,seriously,an idiot? A huge pressure cooker meeting,a GP place at stake,the guy rides like he does for the results he gets,that style goes a long.long way,just look where he is right now,look how far it got him last night too.

 

Nobody moans when it pays off and the entertainment factor's high,but it bites sometimes and today was one of those days,lighten up

 

Good for Harris too,well deserved and hopefully he can make a better go of the 2015 GPs

Well said. Thing is its a so called Swindon fan slating him!!

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I don't recall seeing any post saying how good or bad he is or was. However, the fact remains he finished in the top three of the challenge on merit, ahead of, presumably, other riders who you feel justify being included ahead of him. How so? He has qualified and they haven't, so how poor does that make all of those? Please do think about what you post before you post it.

 

One swallow does not make a summer.

 

I look forward to his usual form returning in the 2015 GP series. He just makes each GP so entertaining to watch!

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Surely they can find a more exciting Pole? He's dull.

Dull but deserving?

Tbf I think he's a little unfairly derided as a gating tart, have seen him involved in some exceptional races. He was arguably the best rider in the world last year, surely along with nki one of two riders guaranteed a wildcard.

Is Bomber the new Andy Smith?

Definitely strong similarities, though think smudger had less wildcards.

Both really excting racers. Both too poor at the start to be contenders at gp level, or even to really dominate at league level. But capable of beating anyone, and certainly good enough in any company outside the truly elite riders.

So hampel and nki surely in now.

Other slots surely dependent on top 8.

Tai greg nicki kk zagar in, and probably holder too.

Think the other spots are two from freddie aj bjerre and batch.

If two swedes qualify, then id expect ward and either mjj/killer.

If swede plus bjerre id expect ward plus thj

If swede plus batch id expect thj plus mjj/killer

If batch plus bjerre id expect two swedes.

 

If ward is banned opens up a range of possibilities for one slot.

The only debate on who should and shouldn't be there is the wild cards... The top 8 and GP qualifiers are there on merit.

 

Everyone saying Harris shouldn't be there yet Doyley deserves to be?? Why?? Doyley isn't that much better than Harris... If at all.... and I doubt bomber has anywhere near the collateral that the big boys have, which is half the battle IMO

Doyle has been one of top 15 riders in the world this year (imho). Harris maybe not top 50. Agree that one of harris' s main issues is his bikes.

But harris has earned his spot fair and square, don't see how anyone can argue to the contrary.

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

We have placed cookies on your device to help make this website better. You can adjust your cookie settings, otherwise we'll assume you're okay to continue. Privacy Policy