Id say youre right that my example is rather illogical.
I made it very much to make the point that it is that type of logic that has previously been applied to suit in previous rulings and there in lies much of theproblem.
It is equally illogical for a rule written in order to assess an average dependant on experience to be able to be interpreted as an average reduction simply because a season ends. The same experience has been gained and isnt reduced because of a calender date.